Looking at the bigger picture: why systems-level stewardship matters for pensions
Long-term prosperity depends on businesses creating value for wider society and the economy too.
This year marks 250 years since Adam Smith published The Wealth of Nations. The economist and moral philosopher's ideas still shape how we think about markets and prosperity today, but some of them are often misunderstood.
One misconception is that businesses have to choose between making a profit and doing good for society. Smith's thinking was more nuanced. Profit matters, but lasting prosperity depends on businesses creating value for society and the economy around them, too.
This has practical implications for asset owners, asset managers and policymakers. Working with the Global Ethical Finance Initiative (GEFI), we explored why Smith's ideas still matter in today's changing world.
Our key conclusion for pension providers? They need to look beyond individual investments and consider the long-term resilience of the wider economy. They need to take a systems-level approach to stewardship.
Transcript
Mark Colegate:
Hello, and welcome to this special Asset TV discussion marking the launch of the Smith250 Executive Brief Series. Earlier this year, GEFI and Royal London launched The Wealth of Nations, Marking 250 Years, and that was at the Ethical Finance Global in Edinburgh, exploring what Adam Smith's ideas can tell us about the purpose and future of markets. And that conversation continued during London Climate Action Week, where GEFI and Royal London brought together authors, senior leaders from across finance, government, business and civil society to consider the practical implications.
Those discussions have now informed three executive briefs, setting out leadership priorities for policymakers, asset owners, and asset managers. And I'm joined now by Barry O'Dwyer, Group CEO of Royal London, who wrote the publication's forward, Markets, Memory and Moral Imagination, to discuss what those priorities mean in practice.
Well, Barry, that's a huge process that you've been going through. Can you tell us what you hope to achieve once you've had to distil this down to the three executive briefs?
Barry O'Dwyer:
Well, I suppose this started with our recognition that the work of Adam Smith was sometimes misinterpreted. The Wealth of Nations is obviously his seminal text, but it shouldn't be read, or it was always intended to be read, alongside The Theory of Moral Sentiments. So, we don't think that Smith saw any distinction between generating profits and acting for the good of society.
And so, what we're trying to achieve with this is to open up that discussion and to have a practical series of briefs that help asset managers and asset owners to understand how they should act in a world where investing responsibly is potentially more important than ever.
Mark Colegate:
Well, one theme that does come out of this is it's not just about individual institutions, but it's about the finance sector working closely with government, business and investors. So, what more do you think is required from financial institutions in this mix?
Barry O'Dwyer:
Well, I suppose ultimately, it's about being responsible owners and investors of the assets that we're the custodians of. Maybe for Royal London, because we're customer owned, we're a mutual organisation, we have a natural tendency to think long-term about our customers' interests. And that's probably helped by the fact that many of our customers are investing their pension money with us, so their time horizon is often over many decades. So that leads us to think very long-term about the investments that we hold and how we can be a responsible owner of these over that long-term period.
Mark Colegate:
You stress the importance of investing for the long term, but how does that necessarily translate into long-term economic growth for the good of society as a whole?
Barry O'Dwyer:
Yeah, I suppose, I mean, our view is that profit is important, but profit has to be grounded in creating longer-term economic value for the societies in which we operate. And so, we think long term about what's best for the society that our customers are going to retire into, whether that's from a social or governance perspective, or even from a climate perspective. So, it leads to us thinking about, well, what sort of investments do we need to have as part of a customer's portfolio? You'll have heard, and the viewers will have heard, of the Mansion House Accord, I imagine. Royal London are signatories to that accord. And what that attempts to do is to invest a proportion of everybody's workplace pension savings into long-term private assets that will be invested for the benefit of society. So, a good example of that might be that we have acquired, in the last 12 months, a business called Dalmore Capital, which is an investor in UK infrastructure projects, and they're the types of projects that I think our customers would like us to see building the infrastructure that the society in which they're going to retire, needs for the future.
Mark Colegate:
And how do you use your influence as an organisation to shape this? Because what you don't want to be doing, I suppose, is ultimately handing over your investors' money purely to government whilst it spends freely with other people's money.
Barry O'Dwyer:
Well, I mean, there's a lot of our investments that we do directly in things like Dalmore. But obviously, we also invest a lot of our customers' money in listed equities, where actually our job becomes making sure that these firms are thinking long term about the delivery of profits. So that comes from, that's basically us using our influence over the companies in which we invest to make sure that they're stewarded correctly, that they're governed well, and that they are thinking about the long-term sustainability of the profits that they generate.
Mark Colegate:
And if you are an investor listening to this, you might say, "you're talking broadly of stewardship".
Barry O'Dwyer:
Yeah.
Mark Colegate:
Where's the proof that long-term stewardship outperforms what, in the old days, used to be called shareholder value – just focus on that bottom line?
Barry O'Dwyer:
I don't think they're incompatible. In fact, over the long term, it's essential. Good stewardship is essential to deliver those long-term returns that our investors, our customers are looking for. So, I don't think there's an inherent contradiction, but it is difficult because stewardship involves a lot of hard work. It involves meeting with the management of the companies in which we operate, if we take equities as an example, influencing them to take seriously some of the things that we think our customers are worried about over the long term, be that climate change or environmental change or social change, and then asking those companies to take action on the back of that. Now, the difficult thing about it, the bit that is challenging, is that sometimes you put in a lot of hard work, and it's very hard to attribute the change that you see to any one individual company's lobbying. And so, we take part in cross-industry groups where we combine with other like-minded asset managers to have these discussions with companies, and we do see real change on the back of that. So, it does work, and it is essential to the generation of long-term value, but it is difficult.
Mark Colegate:
Coming back to this point of influence, I mean, you've talked there about how you can work with individual companies, equities, if you like. But how do you do that with government when you're talking about something like, well, you mentioned pensions earlier, and making sure there's the right environment, the right asset mix, not just for this year and next, but probably 30, 40, 50, 60 years out.
Barry O'Dwyer:
Yeah, I mean, the government is actually very focused on this. So, this is actually where a mutual like Royal London and maybe governments think in the same type of timeframes when they're acting at their best. So, government pension policy, to be fair, does tend to take a very long-term view. And so, a lot of the work that the government has been doing on the Pension Schemes Act and making sure that pension schemes in the UK are consolidated into larger and larger vehicles so that there is a wider spread of assets that customers' money is invested into, and there are access to different types of assets, including, for instance, infrastructure that we talked about earlier. So, governments are, the UK government is keen on that. Now, where we've been trying to sort of influence government is on the specifics of detailed policy. So, for instance, the value for money framework that the government is launching for UK pension funds, it's very, very important that that doesn't just equate price and value, that we look at where the money is being invested. Is it being invested for the long-term good, for the generation of long-term good returns? Because I think that is crucial in seeing the change that we... or sorry, in effecting the change that we want to see in the UK pension landscape.
Mark Colegate:
Again, coming back to those executive briefs, one of the things that's argued in there is that a lot of the financial risk that's in the system can't be teased apart from systemic risk.
Barry O'Dwyer:
Yeah.
Mark Colegate:
It can't be diversified away. How does that change your thinking as an investor or as an asset owner?
Barry O'Dwyer:
Pretty fundamentally because I think, you know, most of us grew up on the idea that diversification was the way in which you spread risk. But of course, with these risks, some of these risks, they can't be diversified away. You can't buy an asset that isn't exposed to geopolitical risk or to climate change risk. And so actually, our focus as an investor is, well, how do we influence the companies that we invest in, the assets that we buy, in order to have a positive impact on mitigating these risks? And that comes, that is the hard yards of just explaining to each company how we think that they should be taking these risks seriously and what they should be doing in order to reflect these risks. And to be fair, with most companies, we're preaching to the converted. But it is making sure that they know that as investors, we value that work, we prize that work, and we want to see them to deliver on that work. So, yeah, it really comes down to using our influence to ensure that companies do the right thing in mitigating these really long-term risks.
Mark Colegate:
Have you got an example of a company that you've successfully engaged with?
Barry O'Dwyer:
Yeah, I mean, there are a few examples. One would be EDF, which is the French state-owned utility company. And EDF have made, I think, tremendous strides in responding to investors like Royal London and our concerns about their usage of gas over the long term, the means by which they will move towards net zero. And this is a company at the sharp edge, and they are taking it very, very seriously. And I think they'd probably be one of the leaders that we would hold out as saying they have taken it seriously, they have made really credible plans – and we and others have encouraged them to do so.
Mark Colegate:
And have you got an example of somewhere where that hasn't worked? How long did it take you to work out this was a relationship and an investment that wasn't going to work out?
Barry O'Dwyer:
Yeah, there are some examples. There are some examples of that. And that is actually more difficult because our instinct, and the instinct of many constructive and particularly active asset managers is to engage, engage, engage, and try and influence change. But sometimes it doesn't work, and as a last resort, we have to divest if we don't think that our engagement is working. And I suppose I can think of one Indonesian bank where we tried to influence the governance. We saw poor governance in action there. We tried to influence. It actually got worse. And so, we made the decision to disinvest, which turned out to be the right decision on all sorts of grounds.
Mark Colegate:
You mentioned an acquisition recently in the alternatives of the private space. But just turning to those private markets and real assets, are they easier to influence and to be an active owner of?
Barry O'Dwyer:
In some senses, yeah. Because I mean, if I take a practical example, we bought thousands of acres of farmland in a joint venture. And so, that farmland is now ours. We influence directly how the land is used. And so, we're using that to improve biodiversity in that part of England. And we're also looking at ways in which we can generate more solar power using some of the land that isn't that productive. So, there are definitely examples where you have physical assets where it is much easier to influence. For other assets, it's much more about influencing management to change.
Mark Colegate:
And in that specific example of buying farmland, is that because fundamentally it's going to be a good source of returns as an investment, or is it there partly as a bit of an offset to other stuff you're doing as well?
Barry O'Dwyer:
No. It first and foremost is there because it's a good asset, and it has a good yield, and it diversifies well across the other asset classes that we hold. So, we're never going do anything with our customers' money which doesn't generate a return, and it's there as a vanity project. But what it does mean is that it gives us some direct influence over how that farmland can be used. And it's 21,000 acres. It's a substantial piece of land. But it's first and foremost there to generate a commercial return.
Mark Colegate:
And how do you think about what the hurdle rate of return is? Because, you know, somebody might say, "Well, that all sounds great in principle, but is he really going put all the money in something that returns 0.5% a year but it's doing good stuff? Surely at some point he's got to invest in things that do 10% a year, and, you know they're not quite as pure, but we've got pensions to pay here."
Barry O'Dwyer:
Well, exactly. I mean, we are trying to generate the best long-term return for our customers but do so in a responsible way. So, there isn't, you know, there isn't any sense that we would bias towards lower returning investment. That's absolutely not what we're trying to do. However, we are trying to invest our customers' money in a diversified range of assets, and we think that natural capital, like farmland, forms part of that. Infrastructure equity, like Dalmore Capital, do. That forms part of it, alongside equities, bonds, property, the usual sort of asset classes that you would expect. So, all of our customers' money is invested across multiple asset classes. But these smaller asset classes, like natural capital, like infrastructure equity, they are important.
Mark Colegate:
And finally, Barry, these three briefs set out priorities for policymakers, for asset owners, and for asset managers. If there's one message you'd like to see all of these leaders take forward from Smith250, what would it be?
Barry O'Dwyer:
I think it's back to something we discussed earlier, that we can't diversify away some of these risks. So, we all have an interest in the health of the system, the health of the economy, and the society in which we operate. And so, I think part of the main takeaway will be that it's incumbent upon us as responsible investors, responsible asset owners, and policymakers to ensure that we look after the health of the system – and that we take the action now that's necessary to deliver those long-term, sustainable, good returns that our customers are looking for.
Mark Colegate:
Barry O'Dwyer, thank you.
Barry O'Dwyer:
Thank you.
Barry O'Dwyer, Royal London Group CEO, summarises why Smith's thinking remains relevant today
What is a systems-level approach to stewardship?
The world has changed a lot since Smith published The Wealth of Nations. Economies, businesses and financial markets globally are now more closely connected than ever. This means an issue in one part of the system can easily affect many others.
Geopolitical tensions can push up energy prices around the world. Extreme heat and other effects of climate change can disrupt agriculture and increase food prices. New technologies such as AI can transform industries.
For pension providers, these systems-level risks are important because they can affect many investments at the same time (albeit in different ways). Systems-level risks can't be avoided by simply diversifying investments across different companies, sectors or markets.
So, looking after customers' investments means looking at the bigger picture. This includes working with government, businesses and wider society to make the whole economy more resilient to systems-level risks.
How does Royal London address systems-level risks?
As a customer-owned business, we exist to serve our customers over the long term, rather than being driven by short-term shareholder returns. Our success depends on the resilience of the wider economy today, but also decades in the future.
We address systems-level risks in how we invest and how we use our influence.
We focus on delivering long-term value for customers. This means we prioritise resilience over short-term gains and invest in areas that support future economic health. For example, we're a signatory to the Mansion House Accord, which aims to secure better financial outcomes for pensions savers by investing in private assets that support economic growth.1 We already meet its requirements through investments in UK-based social housing, care homes and life sciences. And our acquisition of infrastructure manager Dalmore Capital in 2025 further shows our commitment, by continuing to expand our UK infrastructure investments.
We know that well-governed companies are better positioned to navigate periods of uncertainty. That's why we set clear expectations for companies we invest in on their governance and quality of their leadership. We work with companies to address complex challenges, such as how they can adapt to climate change in a way that delivers fair outcomes for their employees and wider society.
As well as engaging with individual firms, we collaborate with policymakers, regulators and industry initiatives. We use our insight and expertise as investors to play our part in shaping policy that helps the economy address systems-level risks, such as the need to transition to more resilient, cleaner energy sources. This also includes promoting a pension system that focuses on long-term value for customers over short-term cost.
We think this approach benefits everyone
Our customers benefit through the delivery of better long-term outcomes for their investments and the society they live in. Businesses benefit by creating long-term value in a responsible way. And the long-term stability of the wider economy is supported through shared prosperity and resilience.
How providers manage systems-level risks should be an important consideration when considering where to invest. Our view is that customers and their advisers should look for providers that invest for the long-term, take an active approach to stewardship and work with policymakers to shape the system.
This is how we can apply Adam Smith's vision now – as relevant today as it was 250 years ago.
Find out more about our work with GEFI on Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations.
1. Signatories pledge to invest 10% of their workplace pension portfolios in private markets by 2030, with at least half allocated to UK growth sectors such as science and technology and supporting greater energy security through investment in clean energy. Private assets are those that are not publicly traded on stock markets.